As Fairlight (Spectrum 128K version) is one of my favorite games, I decided to try and figure out why it fails to run on Mess with the spec128 bios.

I have a z80 game image that loads in & runs fine using Emuzwin. If I load the same image with mess, the game immediately crashes.

I traced the address & opcodes for both Emuzwin and mess, capturing from when the image first loads to when the crash occurs.

Comparing the Emuzwin & mess traces, everything matched to begin with, but then the opcodes started to deviate (after the code calls/jumps to location 0xC000, mess shows opcode 0x49 when it should be 0xE5):

Emuzwin Trace
B70B:D3FD OUT A,13H
B70D:CD000C0 CALL C000H
C000:E5 PUSH HL

Mess Trace
B70B:D3FD OUT A,13H
B70D:CD000C0 CALL C000H
C000:49 LD

After a bit of reading, I made the assumption the crash was due to mess not paging the correct memory bank to address 0xC000. Google-ing things like "Port 0xFD" and "memory paging" I found this (copied from http://www.worldofspectrum.org/rusfaq/):



So it seems the "B70B: D3FD OUT A,13H" (writing 0x13 to the 0xFD port) is a sort of undocumented/shorthand way of paging memory banks that Mess doesn't currently support?

I then had idea of just seeing what happened if I tried to load the z80 image with the 'pentagon' bios (a system I've never heard of until I read the above conversation), and bingo, it worked

I just thought it would be a good idea to mention my findings here, incase Mess-developers aren't aware of this spectrum 128K 0xFD memory paging quirk.

Hope it helps!

I'm not a Speecy guy, but I just wanted to say that's the best bug report I've ever read. Great work

Cheers thanks!

Also just thought I'd mention the same quirk exists for FairlightII 128K version (which also runs fine using the pentagon bios).

thnks for great report. fixed.

pentagon is not just "bios", its separate driver, and already have port decoding for such weird addressing, because a lot of ex-USSR software uses it that way.

didn't know original 128k and +2 have such simplified 7ffd port decoding too. and even worst in the case of reading this port )

That's excellent news! Great to know its resulted in a fix!

By the way just wanted to say, thank you and everyone else for all your hard work on MESS, I really appreciate it

Would this be the appropiate time for a general ZX Spectrum thread, or is it still a low priority compared to other systems?

Spectrum won't be a general thing until we get a cycle-by-cycle Z80.

ICEknight, TBH can't say its "low priority", its more like "no one interested to bother with it"

in my personal TODO list is only task to figure out what kind of dark magic don't let BetaDiskInterface work 100% OK.
already spent quite many time debugging this, and more and more thinking its something wrong in FD17xx emulation code (both legacy and modern implementations)

but, feel free to post issues or wishes )

any plans to add support for .SCL TR-DOS disk images for Russian ZX Spectrum clones in MESS?

last time i checked, they didn't work...

abelenki: nope, but you know where the git repo is ;-)